French Pronouns Y and En: When to Use Each
Getting Started — Two Special Pronouns
Y and en are the two French “adverbial pronouns”. Like the other object pronouns (le/la/les, lui/leur), they shorten a sentence by replacing a repeated word — but they replace a whole preposition + phrase, not just a single noun.
One test carries the whole lesson — remember à versus de:
| What’s in the sentence | Pronoun | Example |
|---|---|---|
| à + place or thing | y | Je vais à Paris → J’y vais. |
| de + noun or quantity | en | Je mange des pommes → J’en mange. |
| à + person | lui / leur | Je parle à Marie → Je lui parle. |
Y — Replacing ‘À’ + Place or Thing
‘Y’ is used most often for places — whether the preposition is à, dans, en, sur, chez, or any other location word:
| Full sentence | With Y |
|---|---|
| Je vais à Montréal. | J’y vais. (I’m going there.) |
| Nous habitons en France. | Nous y habitons. (We live there.) |
| Le livre est sur la table. | Il y est. (It’s there.) |
| Tu vas chez le médecin ? | Oui, j’y vais. (Yes, I’m going there.) |
‘Y’ also replaces ‘à + thing’ (an idea, concept) — especially with penser à, répondre à qqch, réfléchir à:
- “Tu penses à ton avenir ?” → “Oui, j’y pense.” (Yes, I think about it.)
- “Tu réponds à la question ?” → “Oui, j’y réponds.” (Yes, I answer it.)
Attention! For ‘à + person’, don’t use ‘y’ — use lui/leur: “Je pense à Marie” → “Je pense à elle” (for a person, use the stressed pronoun), not “j’y pense”.
En — Replacing ‘De’ + Noun or Quantity
‘En’ appears in three situations, all rooted in de:
1. Partitive (du / de la / des — “some”):
| Full sentence | With En |
|---|---|
| Je mange des pommes. | J’en mange. (I eat some.) |
| Tu bois du café ? | Oui, j’en bois. (Yes, I drink some.) |
| Elle a de la patience. | Elle en a. (She has some.) |
2. Quantity (a number, beaucoup, un peu) — the number stays:
- “Tu as trois frères ?” → “Oui, j’en ai trois.” (Yes, I have three.)
- “Vous avez des questions ?” → “Oui, j’en ai une.” (Yes, I have one.)
- “Tu veux beaucoup de sucre ?” → “Non, j’en veux un peu.” (No, I want a little.)
3. ‘De + thing’ after certain verbs (parler de, avoir besoin de, avoir envie de):
- “Elle parle de son travail ?” → “Oui, elle en parle.” (Yes, she talks about it.)
- “Tu as besoin de ce livre ?” → “Oui, j’en ai besoin.” (Yes, I need it.)
Attention! In a quantity sentence, ‘en’ is required, even when the number is visible: “J’en ai trois” — saying just “J’ai trois” without ‘en’ is incomplete or wrong in French.
Y versus En — How to Tell Them Apart
Look at the preposition after the verb; base your choice on French structure, not English word order:
| Verb + preposition | Pronoun | Example |
|---|---|---|
| aller à, penser à, répondre à (thing) | y | J’y vais. J’y pense. |
| manger du/des, parler de, avoir besoin de | en | J’en mange. J’en parle. |
| habiter à/en/dans (place) | y | Nous y habitons. |
| venir de (place) | en | J’en viens. (I come from there.) |
Placement — Where in the Sentence
Y and en, like other object pronouns, come before the conjugated verb:
| Positive | Negative |
|---|---|
| J’y vais. | Je n’y vais pas. |
| J’en mange. | Je n’en mange pas. |
- Passé composé (before the auxiliary): “J’y suis allé.” “J’en ai mangé.”
- Modal + infinitive (before the infinitive): “Je veux y aller.” “Tu peux en prendre.”
Y and En Together — The Order is ‘y en’
When both appear in one sentence, the order is y first, then en, and both come after the other pronouns:
- “Il y a du pain ?” → “Oui, il y en a.” (Yes, there is some.)
- “Tu mets du lait dans ton café ?” → “Oui, j’y en mets.” (Yes, I put some in it.)
The most common form is il y en a — the pronoun version of ‘il y a’ (there is/are).
Common Everyday Expressions
- On y va ! — Let’s go!
- J’y vais. — I’m off / I’m heading there.
- Il y en a. — There is/are some.
- J’en ai marre. — I’m fed up (of it).
- Je m’en vais. — I’m leaving.
Examples
- “Tu vas souvent au Canada ?” → “Oui, j’y vais chaque année.” (Yes, I go there every year.)
- “Vous voulez du thé ?” → “Oui, j’en veux bien.” (Yes, I’d like some.)
- “Tu penses à tes examens ?” → “Oui, j’y pense tout le temps.” (Yes, I think about them all the time.)
- “Il reste des places ?” → “Oui, il y en a encore.” (Yes, there are still some.)
Common Mistakes and Fixes
| ❌ Wrong | ✓ Right | Explanation |
|---|---|---|
| Je vais y. | J’y vais. | y goes before the verb, not English word order |
| Je pense à Marie → j’y pense. | …je pense à elle. | à + person takes the stressed pronoun, not y |
| J’ai trois. (without en) | J’en ai trois. | Quantity sentences require en, even with the number visible |
| Il en y a. | Il y en a. | The order is y first, then en |
Practise it
Object Pronouns drill includes questions with y and en (alongside le/la/les, lui/leur) — fill in the right pronoun in each sentence, and every answer shows you the full sentence plus the rule.
Next Steps
- Direct & Indirect Object Pronouns (COD/COI) — dive deep into le/la/les and lui/leur.
- All object pronouns overview — all pronouns in one place.
- Prepositions: à, de and others — the à/de distinction that decides whether to use y or en.
Quick tip: Build 5 question-and-answer pairs every day; start with place sentences (y), then quantity sentences (en), then mixed examples like ‘il y en a’.
FAQ
What's the biggest difference between 'Y' and 'En'?
The test is **à versus de**. If the sentence has 'à + place or thing', use **y**: 'Je vais **à** Paris' → 'J'**y** vais'. If it has 'de + noun' or a quantity, use **en**: 'Je parle **de** mon travail' → 'J'**en** parle', 'J'ai **trois** frères' → 'J'**en** ai trois'.
Can 'Y' and 'En' be used for a person?
Usually not. For 'à + person', use **lui/leur**, not 'y': 'Je parle à Marie' → 'Je **lui** parle'. But in quantity sentences, 'en' works for persons too: 'J'ai deux frères' → 'J'**en** ai deux' (you're referring to the count, so 'en' applies).
What happens to the number with 'En'?
The number **stays in the sentence** — only the noun is replaced: 'J'ai **trois** pommes' → 'J'**en** ai **trois**'. 'Combien de frères ? — J'**en** ai deux.' If you drop the number, the sentence feels incomplete.
If both 'y' and 'en' appear in one sentence, what's the order?
**Y comes first, then en** — and both come after other object pronouns. The most common example: 'Il **y a** du pain ?' → 'Oui, il **y en a**.' (Yes, there is some.)